You don't need to have an anal fetish to engage in anal sex, but plenty of people do specifically get off on butt stuff. Anal play can range from adding a finger in the ass during penetrative vaginal sex to using butt plugs to having anal sex with a penis or a dildo. Renye says that one of the most common fetishes centers on something that may be sitting inside your dresser right now: lingerie. #Furry gay xxx knife and shealth professional#.